Posts
295
Comments
27
Trackbacks
206
Google Book Search

Julia is talking about the Google Book Search system, which allows you to search within digitised copies of books. As an author I've though about this, and to some degree the technical field is the one most at risk. After all, technical and reference books are ones that need the search most, and ones whose readership is probably most tech savvy. Someone at a conference once said to Alex "I'd quite happily pay $60 for a book if it had the one piece of information in it I need", and I think many people would. I've been in that situation myself, where an expensive book saved the day because it contained the right piece of information at the time I needed it. The cost was worth it. Would free searching within books negate this sort of buying? Possibly, but I doubt it would actually have much impact.

Part of the appeal of books is their tactile nature. You can site them on your desk and flick through through them. You can easily flip backwards and forwards between different sections. Ebooks, while a useful search tool, don't provide the degree of comfort that a weighty tome does. Sure they weigh less, and you may find the information you need, but think of how much you might learn as you read through a book? I definitely think there's space for both, even with the same book - the carbon based version to flick through, and the virtual version to search and copy code snippets from.

On the fiction front I just can't see this as being a problem. Like Julia, I read almost every night before turning the light out, and I only read fiction at this time. Never tech books. It's my time to escape. I can't ever see a time when I'd like to replace a nice friendly paperback, with a cold hard device, however cool.

[Listening to: The Wanton Song - Led Zeppelin - Physical Graffiti Disc 2]
posted on Wednesday, December 14, 2005 5:07 PM Print
Comments
# re: Google Book Search
Aaron Seet (icelava)
12/30/2005 6:33 PM
Paper vs digital books in this current age is almost like the helicopter vs plane fight. Both have opposing sets of strengths and weakness. I can carry a book and read while i walk, weighty and bulky but no energy cost and not as unwieldy as a flip-open laptop. (I still don't own a sleek slate tablet) I cannot automate fast searches but I can highlight and annotate. On a general whole I still prefer the advantages of paper. Heck, i even print out thousands of lines of code to read and try to understand before i modify.

It may not feel damaging now, but I think as technology catches up on this area, making the digital paper an economically viable reality, book authors can get serious threatened as people conviently download content like music or video and stash in their portal "player". Technologically I can't wait for that to happen (gone with the bulk and weight!), but that will be a mighty challenge for content providers.
# re: Google Book Search
Aaron Seet (icelava)
12/30/2005 6:37 PM
Oh i forgot to mention, my company provides access to books24x7.com and I think I know why I seem to be the only person around who lugs physical books.
 re: Google Book Search
Charlie
12/30/2005 8:19 PM
Either your site is updating slowly or for some other reason wouldn't post my last post
 re: Google Book Search
Charlie
12/30/2005 8:20 PM
Digital books will never replace paper books for me. Although i can see the problem with google books, I can also see the plus side of it.

I really don't think it is anything that will ever have a clear cut winner or looser.

For me, it is the idea that i can search online for books that I normally only have a passing interest in. Considering that I do not make a lot of money, I tend to buy bargin books on subjects like that. Well, cheap books are usually cheap for a reason and that can turn me off from an author.

On the other side, I search the online books because some times i need to know a bit of information but not enough to warrant buying a whole book on the subject.

Works good for me but the author is loosing money. But i am also more prone to remember that author and maybe buy one of his or her other books if it is on a subject that I have more interest in.


If i find something online that i like, I buy it. Mostly because I haven't been able to figure out how to lie on my back in bed, reading my desktop.

Don't know if this little bit of insight from a Joe Blow will help any; but I can tell you that most of the people I know that dabble in technical stuff feel the same way

Take it for what ever it's worth.

BTW I am really enjoying Begining ASP.NET 2.0. Which I will be reading while laying on my bed.

 re: Google Book Search
Dave
12/31/2005 12:04 AM
Sorry about the server slowness - just needed a swift kick to get it working again after the Christmas indulgences.

d
Comments have been closed on this topic.